Why It’s Not a Good Idea to Nail a New Roof Over an Old One

Roof replacement is typically an expensive project. Some homeowners opt for a cheaper way to do this — having the new roof nailed over the old one. In some cases, this method of roof installation is acceptable. But if you want to go with the highest standards and ensure the optimal performance and longevity of your roof system, it’s best to have the old roof stripped off before installing the new one.


Timberland Exteriors, an established provider of residential roofing services, further discusses the top reasons why nailing a new roof over an old one (aka re-roofing) is a bad idea.

Your Roof Warranty Can Be Voided

Roofing warranties typically require that roofs be installed according to the manufacturer’s instructions. If the correct installation method is not followed, your roofing warranty can lose its validity. Keep in mind that the recommended installation techniques help ensure the durability and performance of your roof. So if your roof is not installed using the right method, the manufacturer can no longer guarantee the efficiency of your roof system.

It Adds Unnecessary Weight to Your Home

Your roofing or exterior remodeling contractor will likely raise this issue with regard to re-roofing. Although roofs are generally built to hold a certain weight, a go-over will naturally add an unnecessary load to your roof system. This means your entire roof will likely be absorbing more heat, which could wear out your new shingles more quickly. That said, installing the new shingles directly on the sheathing is recommended.

It Increases the Risk of Roofing Issues

By completely removing the old roof, you’ll have an opportunity to check the condition of the decking and make any necessary repairs or replacements prior to the installation of the new roof. Furthermore, the full removal of the old roof also enables the roofer to properly install the paper underlayment and ice and water shield. These components are crucial to preventing ice dams and protecting your roof from damage.


Timberland Exteriors is a reputable home improvement company with several years of experience in the industry. We perform a variety of jobs including roof replacement, siding installation, hail storm damage restoration, deck construction and more.


Call us at 218-849-6675 or fill out our contact form to request a free quote. We serve customers in Detroit Lakes, Minnesota and the surrounding areas.

Schedule Your

Free Estimate

Contact Us

Convenient Financing Options

We Make Quality Exterior Remodeling Affordable

Beige soffit and gutters on a brick house with a dark shingled roof against a blue sky.
August 15, 2025
When it comes to roof maintenance, most homeowners focus on shingles, flashing, or gutters. But two of the most critical—yet often overlooked—components are the soffit and fascia. These structural elements play a silent but vital role in maintaining your roof’s integrity, ventilation, and overall curb appeal.
A brick house with a gutter on the side of it
July 18, 2025
Gutters play a critical role in the overall health of your home, protecting both its exterior and the foundation. While they are often overlooked, regular gutter maintenance is essential to ensuring that your home remains safe, dry, and structurally sound.
A white house with black shutters on the windows
June 10, 2025
Getting an instant roof quote can save you time and give you a clearer picture of what to expect when it comes to costs.
May 12, 2025
Your roof is one of the most critical components of your home, providing protection from the elements and maintaining the integrity of your living space.
Two men are working on the roof of a house.
April 30, 2025
A roof is one of the most essential parts of your home. It keeps you protected from the elements and plays a critical role in the overall integrity of your house.
A group of people are standing in front of a house under construction.
May 8, 2024
Preparing your home for a roof installation is a crucial step to ensure that the process goes as smoothly as possible. Taking the time to get your home ready can significantly impact the efficiency and success of your roofing project.
A person is opening a window with a white handle.
April 26, 2024
In today’s environment-conscious market, energy-efficient windows have become a core component of home improvement projects, particularly in areas known for their harsh climates, such as Maplewood, MN.
A large white house with a black roof and red shutters
April 22, 2024
As the remnants of winter melt away and the first blooms of spring start gracing us in Maplewood, MN, it’s a signal for many homeowners to start contemplating home improvement projects that were put on hold during the colder months.
A blue house with white trim and a window
April 19, 2024
In the picturesque landscapes of Maplewood, MN, a home’s exterior is the visual handshake it extends to the neighborhood. Maintaining and enhancing the curb appeal of your property is crucial, not only for fostering a sense of pride but also for augmenting the value of your home.
Roof replacement
April 15, 2024
For homeowners in Maplewood, MN, and the surrounding areas, making decisions about roofing can be daunting. There’s a widespread practice known as a “roof-over,” where a new layer of shingles is installed over the existing one, which might seem cost-effective at first glance.
Show More